Stronger Plan Governance. Lower Fiduciary Risk.

Helping employers take control of fiduciary oversight for their health care plans.
Welcome to

Greenleaf Advisors

ERISA has always governed both retirement plans and health & welfare plans.
Yet while most employers have established strong fiduciary practices on the retirement side, the same level of governance has not carried over to their health plans.

Today, that gap carries real risk.

New regulations—including the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA 2021), Hospital Pricing Transparency, and Transparency in Coverage—are finally shining a light on the traditionally opaque healthcare ecosystem. With that transparency, however, comes greater complexity and new expectations for employers:

  • Understanding plan designs, vendor contracts, and compensation
  • Evaluating fees and services for reasonableness
  • Monitoring performance and conflicts of interest
  • Ensuring every decision aligns with fiduciary duties

Most employers simply don’t have the bandwidth or expertise to keep up.

About US

With 30+ years of experience in fiduciary governance, we sit on the same side of the table as the employer. We are independent, unbiased, and pragmatic—focused solely on helping employers fulfill their fiduciary obligations and strengthen their governance process.

We do the heavy lifting so you can confidently demonstrate a prudent, well-documented, and defensible fiduciary process.

Our Services

Comprehensive Risk Audit

Comprehensive Risk Audit

Get a clear view of where your health plan may be exposed - and where savings may be hiding. Our Comprehensive Risk Audit reviews plan operations, pricing transparency requirements, compensation structures, and compliance risk so you can make confident, fiduciary-aligned decisions in today’s increasingly regulated environment.

Read More
Fiduciary Governance & Structure Setup

Fiduciary Governance & Structure Setup

A strong fiduciary process doesn’t happen by accident - it’s built. We help employers establish a formal ERISA fiduciary governance framework with the structure, documentation, and education needed to support consistent oversight, clear accountability, and defensible decision-making.

Read More
Fiduciary Oversight & Risk Mitigation

Fiduciary Oversight & Risk Mitigation

Plan management isn’t “set it and forget it.” We help you move from review to ongoing fiduciary oversight with continuous monitoring, vendor accountability, and data-driven checks that identify issues early, reduce exposure, control costs, and support long-term compliance.

Read More
Fiduciary Governance

For Today’s Benefit Plans

Greenleaf Advisors helps employers reduce fiduciary liability and strengthen oversight across health & welfare plans—an area that has quietly become one of the largest sources of cost and risk for organizations.

Health plans now represent a top-three employer expense, yet they often deliver diminishing value while exposing employers—and the individuals responsible for plan decisions—to increasing legal and fiduciary risk. Despite the size and significance of these plans, they are frequently managed through opaque contracts, withheld data, and conflicted intermediaries, leaving employers without clear visibility or control.

You cannot govern what you cannot see.

The first step in understanding both your exposure and opportunity is gaining clarity on:

  • Where your health plan dollars actually go
  • Who profits from your plan and how
  • How decisions are being made—and whether they align with fiduciary obligations

Without this information, true oversight is impossible.

That’s why we start with a Comprehensive Risk Audit.
This audit provides employers with a clear picture of where fiduciary and compliance exposures exist today, while creating a practical roadmap to transparency, governance, and cost control—so you can regain control with confidence.

Fiduciary Oversight For Self Funded Plans

Fiduciary oversight for self funded plans is the systematic monitoring and governance process that allows employers to satisfy their legal obligations under ERISA while maintaining control over plan operations, cost management, and vendor accountability. For mid-to-large employers in Florida and across the nation managing self-insured health plans, implementing robust oversight structures is not optional-it is the foundation of defensible fiduciary practice.

This guide walks you through the essential steps to establish and maintain effective fiduciary oversight. By the end, you will understand how to audit your current governance gaps, structure decision-making processes, monitor vendor performance, and document your fiduciary decisions in ways that withstand regulatory scrutiny and reduce your organization's liability exposure.

Step 1: Conduct a Comprehensive fiduciary risk audit

Start by mapping your current state. A thorough fiduciary risk audit examines your existing governance framework, vendor contracts, claims administration processes, and decision documentation. The audit identifies where your plan falls short of prudent fiduciary standards and quantifies your exposure to regulatory penalties and litigation.

During this phase, document three critical elements: first, the current roster of fiduciaries and alternates who make decisions about your plan; second, the processes (formal or informal) you currently use to select vendors, review their performance, and make plan design changes; and third, the record-keeping systems you maintain to demonstrate how decisions were made. Greenleaf Advisors conducts this diagnostic work using a structured methodology that compares your actual practices against the fiduciary standards established in ERISA case law and Department of Labor guidance. This creates a baseline from which all subsequent improvements flow.

Step 2: Establish a Formal fiduciary governance framework

Structure your fiduciary decision-making so that it is repeatable, documented, and defensible. A formal governance framework defines who has authority to make which decisions, how information will flow to decision-makers, what criteria will guide those decisions, and how outcomes will be recorded.

At minimum, your framework should include: a written charter that names your fiduciary committee or designates specific individuals as fiduciaries; a documented committee meeting schedule (typically quarterly at minimum for active oversight); a standard agenda template that ensures consistent review of claims data, vendor performance, cost trends, and regulatory developments; and a formal decision-log that captures what was discussed, what was decided, and the business rationale. Because self-funded plans carry heightened fiduciary responsibility-you bear the risk of claims directly-your oversight must be demonstrably more rigorous than a fully-insured plan requires. Greenleaf Advisors helps design these frameworks so they fit your organizational culture and existing governance structures while meeting fiduciary standards.

Key Components of Your Fiduciary Governance Structure

  • Named fiduciaries with written delegation of authority
  • Documented decision-making processes for vendor selection, renewal, and termination
  • Quarterly (or more frequent) plan review meetings with agenda and minutes
  • Written investment policy if your plan holds reserves
  • Claims audit and appeals process documentation
  • Vendor service level agreements with performance metrics and monitoring protocols

Step 3: Implement Ongoing Vendor Performance Monitoring

Self-funded plans depend on third-party administrators, claims processors, and other vendors to execute plan operations. Your fiduciary responsibility includes monitoring these vendors to ensure they perform their contractual obligations and serve the plan prudently. Passive acceptance of vendor reports is not oversight-it is abdication.

Establish a quarterly vendor scorecard that tracks quantifiable metrics: claims processing timeliness (percentage of claims adjudicated within 30 days), accuracy (appeal rates and reversal rates), customer service responsiveness, compliance with plan document provisions, and cost trends relative to benchmarks. Request detailed claims data and actuarial summaries, not just high-level executive summaries. Compare your plan's claims experience against industry benchmarks for your industry and plan design. When vendor performance lags, document the shortfall and your response-whether that is a remediation plan, fee adjustment, or termination. This demonstrable monitoring creates the evidentiary record that distinguishes prudent fiduciary practice from negligent oversight.

Step 4: Conduct Annual Claims and Compliance Audits

Once each year, perform a forensic audit of claims administration. This is distinct from routine monitoring; it examines a statistical sample of actual claims to verify they were processed according to your plan document, that medical necessity determinations were consistent with your plan's terms, and that the claims processor followed your instructions. Many employers discover that vendors have been systematically applying plan provisions differently than intended, or that claims have been incorrectly denied or approved at scale.

The annual audit should also verify that all plan amendments have been properly implemented in the claims system, that exclusions and limitations are being applied uniformly, and that participant appeals are being resolved correctly. Because claims errors can expose your plan to fiduciary liability-particularly if errors systematically benefit the employer or disadvantage certain classes of participants-this step is non-negotiable for self-funded plans. Document your audit methodology, findings, and corrective actions in writing.

Step 5: Maintain Formal Fiduciary Documentation and Training

Fiduciary liability is difficult to defend without a clear, contemporaneous paper trail. Maintain a fiduciary file that contains all meeting minutes, agendas, vendor contracts, performance reports, claims audit findings, and written decisions. This file should be organized chronologically and by decision category (e.g., vendor selection, plan design changes, claims appeal reversals, regulatory compliance actions).

Require all fiduciaries to complete formal training on their ERISA duties, conflict-of-interest policies, and your plan's specific governance procedures. Training should occur annually and whenever a new fiduciary joins the committee. Document attendance and training content. Greenleaf Advisors provides fiduciary certification and training tailored to your plan and your fiduciaries' specific roles, ensuring they understand both the legal landscape and your organization's practical governance structure.

Step 6: Establish a Conflict-of-Interest and Document Retention Policy

Self-funded plans create financial incentives that can cloud fiduciary judgment. If your CFO has a bonus tied to lower healthcare costs, for instance, that person's ability to make unbiased decisions about claims appeals or vendor selection is compromised. Identify potential conflicts and establish protocols to manage them-such as requiring disclosure, recusal from certain decisions, or independent review of contested items.

Define how long you will retain fiduciary documentation (typically a minimum of six years, consistent with DOL guidance) and where those records will be stored. Ensure that records are retrievable if the Department of Labor conducts an audit, if litigation arises, or if a participant files a claim denial appeal. Digital storage with version control and audit trails is preferable to paper; either way, ensure that no single person can unilaterally delete or modify fiduciary records.

Implementing fiduciary oversight for self funded plans requires discipline, but it yields measurable benefits: reduced regulatory risk, stronger vendor relationships based on documented performance standards, fewer claims disputes, and defensible documentation if your practices are ever questioned. The process is ongoing-each decision, each vendor review, and each audit feeds back into your governance framework, making it more refined and more resilient.

If your organization is ready to strengthen its fiduciary governance or audit your current oversight practices, Greenleaf Advisors stands ready to help. With 30 years of experience guiding employers through ERISA compliance and fiduciary decision-making, we understand the regulatory landscape and the practical challenges you face. Contact us to discuss how a comprehensive fiduciary governance assessment can reduce your liability and improve your plan's operations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between fiduciary oversight and plan administration?

Plan administration is the execution of day-to-day operations-processing claims, sending statements, collecting premiums. Fiduciary oversight is the governance layer above administration; it means monitoring whether administrators are performing correctly, making prudent decisions about plan design and vendor selection, and documenting those decisions. A fiduciary can outsource administration, but cannot outsource oversight responsibility.

How often should a self-funded plan conduct fiduciary meetings?

At minimum quarterly, though many plans benefit from more frequent review during times of regulatory change or significant claims volatility. Regular meetings demonstrate that the fiduciary committee is actively engaged, not rubber-stamping vendor recommendations. Meeting frequency should be documented in your governance charter.

What specific metrics should I monitor for my third-party claims administrator?

Track claims processing timeliness (percentage adjudicated within 30 days), appeals rate, reversal rate on appeal, customer service response time, compliance with plan document provisions, and cost per claim against benchmarks. Request detailed supporting data quarterly, not just summary reports.

Is fiduciary oversight for self funded plans required by law?

Yes. ERISA Section 404(a) requires fiduciaries to act prudently and in the interest of plan participants, to follow plan documents, and to diversify plan investments to minimize risk. These duties apply to all plan fiduciaries, including those managing self-funded health plans. Failure to exercise these duties exposes fiduciaries to personal liability and regulatory penalties.

How long must we retain fiduciary decision documentation?

The Department of Labor expects fiduciary records to be retained for at least six years. In practice, many employers retain records for seven to ten years to account for statute-of-limitations periods on legal claims. Digital storage with clear version history and audit trails is recommended.

What should I do if my annual claims audit uncovers systematic errors by the claims administrator?

Document the errors, quantify the financial impact, and notify the administrator in writing. Require a corrective action plan with timeline and remediation for affected participants. If errors are material or patterns repeat, consider renegotiating fees, requiring additional oversight, or terminating the vendor relationship. Always document your response in the fiduciary file.

Does Greenleaf Advisors help employers in Florida establish fiduciary oversight?

Yes. Greenleaf Advisors provides comprehensive risk audits, fiduciary governance framework setup, and ongoing compliance monitoring for mid-to-large employers nationwide, including Florida-based organizations. We work with plan sponsors to build defensible, prudent fiduciary structures tailored to their plans and organizational needs.

DID YOU KNOW

Employers have a legal obligation to act in the sole interest of plan participants.
Between 15% and 25% of health care dollars are consumed by administrative expenses, totaling hundreds of billions of dollars each year.
Employer cost-reduction efforts are often undermined by intermediary incentives that are not aligned with plan sponsor interests.

Contact Us

We are here to help!

info@greenleafadvisorgroup.com