Stronger Plan Governance. Lower Fiduciary Risk.

Helping employers take control of fiduciary oversight for their health care plans.
Welcome to

Greenleaf Advisors

ERISA has always governed both retirement plans and health & welfare plans.
Yet while most employers have established strong fiduciary practices on the retirement side, the same level of governance has not carried over to their health plans.

Today, that gap carries real risk.

New regulations—including the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA 2021), Hospital Pricing Transparency, and Transparency in Coverage—are finally shining a light on the traditionally opaque healthcare ecosystem. With that transparency, however, comes greater complexity and new expectations for employers:

  • Understanding plan designs, vendor contracts, and compensation
  • Evaluating fees and services for reasonableness
  • Monitoring performance and conflicts of interest
  • Ensuring every decision aligns with fiduciary duties

Most employers simply don’t have the bandwidth or expertise to keep up.

About US

With 30+ years of experience in fiduciary governance, we sit on the same side of the table as the employer. We are independent, unbiased, and pragmatic—focused solely on helping employers fulfill their fiduciary obligations and strengthen their governance process.

We do the heavy lifting so you can confidently demonstrate a prudent, well-documented, and defensible fiduciary process.

Our Services

Comprehensive Risk Audit

Comprehensive Risk Audit

Get a clear view of where your health plan may be exposed - and where savings may be hiding. Our Comprehensive Risk Audit reviews plan operations, pricing transparency requirements, compensation structures, and compliance risk so you can make confident, fiduciary-aligned decisions in today’s increasingly regulated environment.

Read More
Fiduciary Governance & Structure Setup

Fiduciary Governance & Structure Setup

A strong fiduciary process doesn’t happen by accident - it’s built. We help employers establish a formal ERISA fiduciary governance framework with the structure, documentation, and education needed to support consistent oversight, clear accountability, and defensible decision-making.

Read More
Fiduciary Oversight & Risk Mitigation

Fiduciary Oversight & Risk Mitigation

Plan management isn’t “set it and forget it.” We help you move from review to ongoing fiduciary oversight with continuous monitoring, vendor accountability, and data-driven checks that identify issues early, reduce exposure, control costs, and support long-term compliance.

Read More
Fiduciary Governance

For Today’s Benefit Plans

Greenleaf Advisors helps employers reduce fiduciary liability and strengthen oversight across health & welfare plans—an area that has quietly become one of the largest sources of cost and risk for organizations.

Health plans now represent a top-three employer expense, yet they often deliver diminishing value while exposing employers—and the individuals responsible for plan decisions—to increasing legal and fiduciary risk. Despite the size and significance of these plans, they are frequently managed through opaque contracts, withheld data, and conflicted intermediaries, leaving employers without clear visibility or control.

You cannot govern what you cannot see.

The first step in understanding both your exposure and opportunity is gaining clarity on:

  • Where your health plan dollars actually go
  • Who profits from your plan and how
  • How decisions are being made—and whether they align with fiduciary obligations

Without this information, true oversight is impossible.

That’s why we start with a Comprehensive Risk Audit.
This audit provides employers with a clear picture of where fiduciary and compliance exposures exist today, while creating a practical roadmap to transparency, governance, and cost control—so you can regain control with confidence.

Health Plan Vendor Oversight

Monitoring and managing the performance, compliance, and financial practices of third-party vendors administering your health and welfare plans is health plan vendor oversight, and it is among the most consequential-and most overlooked-fiduciary responsibilities plan sponsors carry. Vendors including TPAs (third-party administrators), brokers, consultants, and carriers operate within your plan structure, yet many employers lack systematic processes to verify that these vendors are acting in the plan's best interest, complying with regulatory requirements, or performing at market rates. This gap creates genuine fiduciary exposure and unnecessarily inflates costs across health benefits administration.

Mid-to-large employers across Florida and nationwide face an operating environment where vendor relationships have become increasingly complex. Self-insured plans and fully-insured arrangements both require active oversight to ensure vendors are not extracting unnecessary profit at the plan's expense, complying with Department of Labor standards, or introducing compliance risks that flow back to the plan sponsor. Greenleaf Advisors has spent more than 30 years helping plan sponsors establish the frameworks, processes, and governance structures needed to exercise genuine fiduciary control over vendor relationships-transforming vendor oversight from a reactive problem into a defensible, documented practice.

Why Vendor Oversight Is Foundational to Fiduciary Governance

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) defines plan sponsors as fiduciaries responsible for the prudent selection and ongoing monitoring of all service providers. This obligation is not theoretical. When a vendor fails to comply with plan documents, overcharges the plan, or mishandles participant data, the plan sponsor's fiduciary liability is engaged. Courts and the Department of Labor consistently hold that passive acceptance of vendor invoices or annual reports does not satisfy the fiduciary standard of care. You must actively monitor.

Vendor oversight failures typically manifest in three categories: cost overruns through hidden fees or inflated service charges, compliance breaches in claims handling or data security, and conflicts of interest where vendors prioritize their own margins over plan economics. Because these issues often remain invisible without systematic monitoring protocols, plan sponsors inadvertently expose themselves to audit findings, litigation, and remediation obligations. Greenleaf Advisors builds comprehensive vendor oversight frameworks that document the selection criteria, performance metrics, compliance checkpoints, and fee benchmarking needed to satisfy the prudent fiduciary standard.

Establishing Vendor Performance Benchmarks and Fee Transparency

Effective vendor oversight requires measurable performance standards and transparent fee structures. Most vendors operate with opaque pricing models where the full cost of service-administrative fees, markup structures, revenue-sharing arrangements, and contingent compensation-remains partially hidden from plan sponsors. Without baseline benchmarks, you cannot determine whether your TPAs charges, your broker commission, or your consultant fees are reasonable.

Greenleaf Advisors conducts comprehensive market analyses to establish performance benchmarks specific to your plan demographics, geography, and service model. This process includes:

  • Comparing your vendors' administrative fees against market rates for plans of similar size and complexity
  • Documenting all revenue sources vendors receive from your plan, including direct fees, spread charges on pharmacy or dental networks, risk management fees, and contingent compensation
  • Establishing service level agreements (SLAs) with measurable targets: claims processing turnaround times (typically 10-15 days for clean claims), participant communication response standards, and compliance milestone completion dates
  • Creating a fee verification protocol requiring vendors to provide annual attestations of all compensation sources and changes to their compensation model

Once benchmarks are established, ongoing monitoring becomes structured. Quarterly vendor performance reviews should measure actual results against agreed SLAs. Annual fee audits should verify that vendors have disclosed all compensation streams and that rates remain competitive relative to market. Because vendors know they are being actively monitored and measured, this transparency itself often leads to improved performance and fee rationalization.

Compliance Monitoring and Risk Mitigation Through Vendor Audits

Vendors operate within a complex regulatory environment. TPAs must comply with claims handling regulations under state insurance law. Brokers must honor broker neutrality requirements and disclose conflicts of interest. All vendors handling personal health information must satisfy HIPAA security and privacy standards. As a plan sponsor, you are responsible for ensuring these obligations are being met, even though vendors execute the work.

Systematic compliance monitoring requires three parallel processes. First, establish contractual audit rights allowing your firm (or retained advisors) to conduct on-site reviews of vendor operations, compliance controls, and data security practices. Most vendor contracts limit audit rights; Greenleaf Advisors helps plan sponsors negotiate clauses permitting annual audits and access to relevant compliance documentation. Second, implement annual compliance certifications requiring vendors to attest in writing to their regulatory compliance status, confirmation of required insurance coverage, and disclosure of any regulatory inquiries or litigation affecting their operations. Third, track vendor incident reports-claims denials that are later overturned, data breaches, regulatory inquiries-to identify systemic compliance weaknesses before they escalate.

Beyond annual reviews, proactive risk assessments should focus on the vendors handling the highest-risk functions. For TPAs, this includes claims adjudication accuracy and HIPAA compliance. For brokers, this includes compensation disclosure and conflicts of interest management. For consultants, this includes the independence of their recommendations relative to their financial interests. Greenleaf Advisors' risk audits identify specific compliance gaps and recommend corrective actions with documented deadlines, converting compliance from a theoretical obligation into an executed practice.

Documentation, Governance, and Defensible Decision-Making

The fiduciary standard requires not only prudent decisions but documented, defensible decisions. When a vendor is selected, retained, or terminated, the plan sponsor must maintain a contemporaneous record of the analysis supporting that decision. This documentation serves two purposes: it demonstrates to regulators and courts that the fiduciary acted prudently, and it creates organizational memory so that decisions are not rehashed annually without institutional learning.

A defensible vendor oversight governance structure includes written policies that specify how vendors will be selected, what performance criteria will be evaluated, how conflicts of interest will be managed, and what documentation will be maintained. Greenleaf Advisors works with plan sponsors to establish fiduciary governance frameworks that institutionalize this process across your organization. The framework typically includes a designated fiduciary committee with defined roles, a documented process for vendor evaluation and renewal, a schedule of compliance touchpoints throughout the year, and templates for vendor performance scorecards and audit findings.

This structure matters because it ensures continuity. When benefits managers or HR executives transition, the vendor oversight process does not deteriorate; it continues because it is embedded in policy and process. When a vendor requests a fee increase or contract modification, the plan sponsor reviews it against documented benchmarks and prior performance, not on an ad hoc basis. Documentation also becomes invaluable if a vendor fails to perform and the plan incurs losses; the sponsor's record of diligent oversight demonstrates that the failure was a vendor breach, not a fiduciary breach.

Practical Recommendations for Implementing Effective Vendor Oversight

Plan sponsors looking to strengthen their vendor oversight can implement these foundational practices immediately:

  1. Conduct a comprehensive vendor fee audit. Request detailed fee schedules from every vendor and reconcile those fees against invoices for the past two years. Identify any undisclosed revenue sources or fee changes. Greenleaf Advisors typically finds 8-15% cost reduction opportunities through this single exercise.
  2. Establish a vendor performance scorecard. Define 8-12 specific metrics across quality, compliance, and cost categories. Review vendor performance quarterly against these metrics. Documentation of underperformance creates a paper trail if vendor changes become necessary.
  3. Negotiate audit rights into vendor contracts. If your current contracts do not explicitly permit on-site audits and access to compliance documentation, renegotiate these terms before renewal. Vendors should expect oversight; resistance to audit rights is itself a risk signal.
  4. Create a compliance certification process. Issue annual written certifications requiring vendors to attest to their regulatory status, insurance coverage, and absence of material compliance incidents. Make certification completion a contractual requirement.
  5. Document all material vendor decisions in writing. When a vendor is selected, why were competing proposals rejected? When fees are negotiated, what analysis supports the agreed rate? When performance issues are identified, what corrective actions were requested and by what deadline? Written decisions create defensibility.

Greenleaf Advisors helps plan sponsors across Florida and nationwide implement these practices through comprehensive risk audits that identify vendor oversight gaps, fiduciary governance framework setup that creates policy and process infrastructure, and ongoing compliance monitoring that ensures these systems remain active and effective. The goal is simple: transform vendor relationships from a source of fiduciary anxiety into a documented, managed practice that reduces both risk and cost.

If your organization would benefit from an assessment of your current vendor oversight practices or would like to discuss how to strengthen your fiduciary governance structure, Greenleaf Advisors invites you to reach out. We work with plan sponsors to convert complexity into clarity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What specific vendor oversight responsibilities does ERISA impose on plan sponsors?

ERISA requires plan sponsors to prudently select vendors based on their qualifications and fees, monitor their ongoing performance and compliance, and ensure they are acting in the plan's best interest. This includes verifying that vendors comply with applicable regulations, that fees remain competitive, and that vendors disclose all compensation sources. Passive acceptance of vendor reports does not satisfy this fiduciary duty; active, documented monitoring is required.

How often should we audit our health plan vendors?

Annual compliance audits are the fiduciary baseline, with quarterly performance reviews against documented service level agreements. Higher-risk vendors-those handling claims adjudication, participant data, or significant financial transactions-warrant more frequent review. The specific frequency depends on your plan size, vendor complexity, and risk profile. Greenleaf Advisors tailors audit schedules to your circumstances.

What hidden fees should plan sponsors be aware of in health plan administration?

Common hidden or undisclosed vendor charges include TPA spread charges on pharmacy and dental networks, broker revenue-sharing arrangements with carriers or vendors, consultant contingent compensation tied to plan design changes, and administrative fee increases that are not clearly communicated. Systematic fee audits and vendor fee disclosure requirements help identify these costs so plan sponsors can assess whether they are reasonable and compliant.

How do we establish vendor performance benchmarks for our plan?

Performance benchmarking requires comparing your vendors' fees, service standards, and operational practices against market data for comparable plans. This includes analyzing administrative fees against market rates for your plan's demographics and service model, measuring vendor performance against agreed service level agreements (such as claims processing turnaround times), and benchmarking vendor compliance practices against industry standards. Greenleaf Advisors conducts market analyses specific to your plan to establish credible benchmarks.

What should be included in a vendor audit rights clause?

Audit rights should explicitly permit the plan sponsor (or retained advisors) to conduct on-site audits of vendor operations at least annually, require vendors to provide access to compliance documentation and data security records, allow reviews of claims adjudication practices and accuracy metrics, and specify the vendor's obligation to remediate audit findings within a defined timeframe. Strong audit rights clauses also reserve the right to engage third-party auditors and require vendors to cooperate with regulatory investigations.

Does Greenleaf Advisors help plan sponsors in Florida establish vendor oversight processes?

Yes. Greenleaf Advisors works with mid-to-large employers across Florida and nationwide to conduct comprehensive vendor risk audits, establish fiduciary governance frameworks that institutionalize vendor oversight, and implement ongoing compliance monitoring systems. Our process identifies vendor oversight gaps, documents performance metrics, and creates the policies and procedures needed to satisfy your fiduciary duties while reducing costs and compliance risk.

DID YOU KNOW

Employers have a legal obligation to act in the sole interest of plan participants.
Between 15% and 25% of health care dollars are consumed by administrative expenses, totaling hundreds of billions of dollars each year.
Employer cost-reduction efforts are often undermined by intermediary incentives that are not aligned with plan sponsor interests.

Contact Us

We are here to help!

info@greenleafadvisorgroup.com