Stronger Plan Governance. Lower Fiduciary Risk.
Helping employers take control of fiduciary oversight for their health care plans.
Welcome to
Greenleaf Advisors
ERISA has always governed both retirement plans and health & welfare plans.
Yet while most employers have established strong fiduciary practices on the retirement side, the same level of governance has not carried over to their health plans.
Today, that gap carries real risk.
New regulations—including the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA 2021), Hospital Pricing Transparency, and Transparency in Coverage—are finally shining a light on the traditionally opaque healthcare ecosystem. With that transparency, however, comes greater complexity and new expectations for employers:
- Understanding plan designs, vendor contracts, and compensation
- Evaluating fees and services for reasonableness
- Monitoring performance and conflicts of interest
- Ensuring every decision aligns with fiduciary duties
Most employers simply don’t have the bandwidth or expertise to keep up.
About US
With 30+ years of experience in fiduciary governance, we sit on the same side of the table as the employer. We are independent, unbiased, and pragmatic—focused solely on helping employers fulfill their fiduciary obligations and strengthen their governance process.
We do the heavy lifting so you can confidently demonstrate a prudent, well-documented, and defensible fiduciary process.

Our Services

Comprehensive Risk Audit
Get a clear view of where your health plan may be exposed - and where savings may be hiding. Our Comprehensive Risk Audit reviews plan operations, pricing transparency requirements, compensation structures, and compliance risk so you can make confident, fiduciary-aligned decisions in today’s increasingly regulated environment.
Read More
Fiduciary Governance & Structure Setup
A strong fiduciary process doesn’t happen by accident - it’s built. We help employers establish a formal ERISA fiduciary governance framework with the structure, documentation, and education needed to support consistent oversight, clear accountability, and defensible decision-making.
Read More
Fiduciary Oversight & Risk Mitigation
Plan management isn’t “set it and forget it.” We help you move from review to ongoing fiduciary oversight with continuous monitoring, vendor accountability, and data-driven checks that identify issues early, reduce exposure, control costs, and support long-term compliance.
Read More
Fiduciary Governance
For Today’s Benefit Plans
Greenleaf Advisors helps employers reduce fiduciary liability and strengthen oversight across health & welfare plans—an area that has quietly become one of the largest sources of cost and risk for organizations.
Health plans now represent a top-three employer expense, yet they often deliver diminishing value while exposing employers—and the individuals responsible for plan decisions—to increasing legal and fiduciary risk. Despite the size and significance of these plans, they are frequently managed through opaque contracts, withheld data, and conflicted intermediaries, leaving employers without clear visibility or control.
You cannot govern what you cannot see.
The first step in understanding both your exposure and opportunity is gaining clarity on:
- Where your health plan dollars actually go
- Who profits from your plan and how
- How decisions are being made—and whether they align with fiduciary obligations
Without this information, true oversight is impossible.
That’s why we start with a Comprehensive Risk Audit.
This audit provides employers with a clear picture of where fiduciary and compliance exposures exist today, while creating a practical roadmap to transparency, governance, and cost control—so you can regain control with confidence.
What Is A Healthcare Fiduciary
A healthcare fiduciary is a person or organization with legal authority and responsibility to make decisions about an employer's health and welfare plans-and to act in the best interest of plan participants, not the company's bottom line. If you sponsor a health plan, someone in your organization is already a fiduciary, whether that title appears on a business card or not. Greenleaf Advisors helps employers across Florida and nationwide understand this role and execute it defensibly.
Most mid-to-large employers don't fully grasp how broad fiduciary responsibility actually runs. A benefits manager approving a plan change, an HR executive negotiating with a health insurance carrier, a finance leader reviewing vendor contracts-each of these is acting in a fiduciary capacity. The legal standard is unforgiving: fiduciaries must act prudently, loyally, and within the documents governing the plan. When they don't, personal and corporate liability follows.
The confusion deepens because fiduciary duty operates silently. No one sends a formal notice saying you've become a fiduciary. No licensing board certifies competence. Yet the stakes are real. A single imprudent decision-selecting an underperforming health plan without competitive analysis, retaining a broker with undisclosed conflicts, failing to monitor vendor fees-can expose individuals and the organization to Department of Labor investigations, participant lawsuits, and settlements that reach six or seven figures.
The Legal Foundation: ERISA and Fiduciary Duty
Healthcare fiduciary duties flow from the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, known as ERISA. This federal law, enacted decades ago, holds plan fiduciaries to a standard that is more demanding than ordinary business judgment. Under ERISA, fiduciaries must discharge their duties solely in the interest of participants and beneficiaries, with the care and diligence a prudent expert would exercise.
That last phrase-"a prudent expert"-is the legal linchpin. Fiduciaries are measured against an objective standard, not their own good intentions. If a plan sponsor retained a broker without reviewing fees, or renewed a health plan without competitive bidding, courts ask whether a prudent expert in the benefits industry would have done the same. Usually, the answer is no.
ERISA fiduciaries cannot delegate their liability away. Even if you hire a third-party administrator or consultant, you remain responsible for prudent oversight of that vendor's performance and fees.
The law identifies three core duties. First, fiduciaries must act prudently-meaning they must gather relevant facts, seek competitive options, document decisions, and monitor results. Second, they must act with undivided loyalty to the plan, not pursuing their own interests or the company's interests at participants' expense. Third, they must comply with plan documents and ERISA's rules themselves.
Because ERISA applies to self-insured and fully-insured plans alike, no employer is too small to worry about fiduciary compliance. But mid-to-large organizations with complex vendor ecosystems and significant healthcare spend face the greatest exposure. That's where fiduciary governance-the deliberate structures and processes Greenleaf Advisors establishes-becomes essential.
Who Becomes a Fiduciary, and What They Must Do
Fiduciary status is not always obvious from a job title. You become a fiduciary the moment you exercise discretion over plan management or participant funds. This can include the chief financial officer making investment decisions for a health reimbursement arrangement, the benefits director selecting health plans, the compensation committee approving plan changes, or an outside consultant advising on plan design.
Many organizations unknowingly spread fiduciary responsibility across multiple people and departments. A broker may handle vendor negotiations, but the plan sponsor remains liable for oversight. An administrator may process claims, but the fiduciary must ensure the administrator is performing correctly. Insurance carriers may manage networks, but the fiduciary bears the duty to verify that network adequacy and claims practices serve participants fairly.
This fragmented accountability is where risk accumulates. Without clear governance, no one owns the decision. Without documentation, no one can prove the decision was prudent. Without monitoring, bad vendor performance persists uncorrected. Employers working with Greenleaf Advisors establish fiduciary governance frameworks that clarify roles, assign accountability, and build an audit trail showing prudent decision-making at each step.
The practical duties vary by role. Plan sponsors must select and monitor third-party service providers, review plan documents for compliance with law, and ensure the plan's terms are communicated truthfully to participants. Fiduciaries managing health plan decisions must understand the plans they offer, evaluate them against alternatives, and document why one option is prudent relative to others. Those overseeing vendor relationships must track fees, performance metrics, and conflicts of interest, questioning whether the arrangement still serves participants cost-effectively.
None of these tasks requires advanced financial engineering. They require discipline, documentation, and a systematic approach. Because benefit plans serve thousands of participants whose healthcare dollars depend on prudent management, the law treats failure to execute these tasks seriously.
Fiduciary Risk in Practice: Where Employers Stumble
Most fiduciary lapses fall into predictable patterns. The first is inadequate competitive process. An employer renews a health plan for five years without requesting competitive bids, assuming the incumbent carrier is the default choice. Under ERISA's prudence standard, this is indefensible. A prudent expert would always test the market, even if the incumbent plan ultimately wins the renewal.
The second is failure to disclose and manage conflicts of interest. A broker earns higher commissions from certain carriers, but never discloses this fact. A consultant advises on plan design while also providing claim administration services. The fiduciary uses the consultant's recommendation without recognizing the conflict. These scenarios expose fiduciaries to liability for breach of the duty of loyalty.
The third is inadequate vendor monitoring. A plan sponsor signs a contract with a health plan, administrator, or pharmacy benefit manager, then assumes the vendor will perform appropriately without oversight. Years pass. Claims denials spike. Network participation drops. Fees rise above market. The fiduciary discovers these problems only when a participant complains or an audit surfaces them. By then, the fiduciary has already breached the duty of prudence by failing to monitor.
The fourth is poor documentation. A fiduciary makes a reasonable decision but keeps no record of how the decision was reached, what alternatives were considered, or why the chosen option was prudent. When questioned later, the fiduciary cannot reconstruct the analysis. In litigation, this silence is read as carelessness or, worse, bad faith.
Greenleaf Advisors addresses each of these gaps through comprehensive risk audits that surface where governance is weak, through fiduciary governance setup that installs the right decision-making structures and documentation disciplines, and through ongoing oversight that keeps vendor performance and compliance on track.
Building Defensible Fiduciary Governance
The path forward starts with clarity. Plan sponsors need to understand exactly who is making decisions about the health plan, under what authority, and with what oversight. They need to know which vendors are critical to plan performance and how often those vendors are being evaluated. They need to document the reasoning behind key decisions so that if a complaint or audit arises, they can show their work.
A fiduciary governance framework built with Greenleaf Advisors typically includes defined roles and responsibilities, a documented decision-making process for plan changes and vendor selections, a schedule for competitive evaluation of major vendors, a monitoring protocol that tracks vendor performance against agreed metrics, and a training program so that fiduciaries understand their legal duties and how the governance process supports compliance.
For employers in Florida and across the country managing self-insured or fully-insured health plans, this structure is not burdensome overhead-it is the difference between facing an audit with confidence and facing it with dread. Because fiduciary duty is ongoing, not a one-time box to check, many employers benefit from a retained advisor who monitors the regulatory landscape, reviews plan documents for compliance, and alerts leadership when governance needs adjustment.
If you're uncertain whether your organization is managing healthcare fiduciary responsibility effectively, or if you've experienced a benefits audit and want to prevent future exposure, Greenleaf Advisors is equipped to assess your current governance, identify gaps, and establish the frameworks and oversight needed to protect both participants and your organization. We work with plan sponsors and HR teams to translate fiduciary law into practical, defensible action.
Reach out to discuss a risk audit or to learn how fiduciary governance can reduce your liability and improve your health plan's performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a plan sponsor and a plan fiduciary?
A plan sponsor is the employer that establishes and maintains the health plan. A plan fiduciary is any person or entity with authority to make decisions about the plan or control over plan assets or information. The plan sponsor is always a fiduciary, but fiduciaries can also include individual employees, consultants, administrators, and third-party service providers who exercise discretion over plan operations.
Can I delegate my fiduciary duties to a consultant or broker?
You can hire consultants and brokers to help you carry out fiduciary duties, but you cannot delegate your fiduciary liability. Even if you retain an outside advisor, you remain responsible for prudently selecting that advisor, overseeing their performance, and ensuring their recommendations serve participants' interests. This is why ongoing vendor monitoring is a core fiduciary responsibility.
What does it mean to act prudently as a healthcare fiduciary?
Acting prudently means making decisions the way a knowledgeable expert in the benefits industry would. This includes gathering relevant information, considering competitive alternatives, documenting the decision-making process, and monitoring the results. Prudence is measured by the process you follow and the care you exercise, not by whether the outcome was perfect.
What are the consequences of failing to meet fiduciary duties?
Failure to meet fiduciary duties can result in Department of Labor investigations, participant lawsuits, personal liability for fiduciaries, corporate penalties, and settlement costs. Beyond legal exposure, poor governance can lead to overpayment for health services, inadequate plan performance, and loss of trust with participants.
How often should we review our health plan vendors for fiduciary compliance?
Major vendors, such as health plans and administrators, should be formally evaluated at least annually and competitively bid every three to five years, unless a gap analysis documents that the incumbent remains optimal. Ongoing monitoring of claims performance, network adequacy, and fees should occur continuously. The frequency depends on plan size, complexity, and any performance issues that emerge.
Do fiduciary duties apply to fully-insured health plans, or only self-insured plans in Florida?
Fiduciary duties apply to both fully-insured and self-insured health plans under ERISA. While a carrier assumes some claims responsibilities in a fully-insured arrangement, the plan sponsor remains a fiduciary responsible for selecting the carrier prudently, monitoring its performance, and ensuring plan terms serve participants fairly.
What should we document to demonstrate prudent fiduciary decision-making?
Document the alternatives you considered, the selection criteria you used, the competitive analysis you conducted, the cost comparisons, meeting minutes where decisions were discussed, and the reasons you chose the option you did. Keep records of ongoing vendor monitoring, including performance metrics, fee audits, and any corrective actions taken. This documentation is your evidence that you acted as a prudent expert would.

DID YOU KNOW
Employers have a legal obligation to act in the sole interest of plan participants.
Between 15% and 25% of health care dollars are consumed by administrative expenses, totaling hundreds of billions of dollars each year.
Employer cost-reduction efforts are often undermined by intermediary incentives that are not aligned with plan sponsor interests.
